Keep In Touch

Choosing Freedom…and Trusting Women

Posted by: Cheryl Kagan on Friday, January 22, 2010 at 1:08:40 am

Choosing Freedom…and Trusting Women

Post #31

I recently got a fortune cookie with a more profound message than usual.  It said: “You value freedom- -grant it to others.”

This struck me as a perfect thought, as today is the 37th anniversary of the Supreme Court’s decision in Roe v. Wade.  I’m sure my blog readers know that this landmark case legalized abortion, describing what is legally permissible based on each trimester of gestation. It struck a balance between a woman’s right to control her body with the government’s role in protecting potential life.  The late Justice Harry Blackmun, the decision’s author, clearly trusted women to make their own decisions.

Although decided in our nation’s highest court, the battle over a woman’s right to choose has continued these past decades.  In addition to fighting electoral and legislative battles as allowed by law, some anti-abortion extremists have sadly selected violence as their preferred tactic. 

They began by picketing clinics and harassing prospective patients.  This was effective but not a quick enough means.  Then came the arsons, death threats and a rash of clinic bombings.  Not only did these destroy valuable medical equipment that provided needed health care, but a total of eight people (four doctors, two clinic staffers, a security guard and an escort) were murdered.  Last May, a leading abortion foe, Scott Roeder, assassinated Dr. George Tiller while Tiller was volunteering in his church in Kansas.  Ironically, the jurors in Roeder’s trial began hearing testimony in his trial today.

The right place to debate this emotional, moral, medical, and deeply personal issue is in legislative chambers, at the ballot box, and in peaceful assemblies.  Those who value freedom should cherish the Right to Assemble, the Right to Free Speech, and the Right to cast a vote for the candidates they prefer.  Any other means of trying to realize victory is antithetical to our American values… and in gross violation of the freedoms that we American citizens are blessed to enjoy.

On this 37th anniversary of Roe v. Wade, I would hope that Americans could celebrate our freedoms… and renew our trust in our mothers, daughters, sisters, and friends to make decisions about when and whether to bear children.  Soon after college graduation, I worked on the staff at national NARAL and continue to be a devoted advocate for a woman's right to choose. I have long supported the Maryland affiliate of NARAL in its work to stand up for the women of our state.  Will you join me?

I would love to hear from you, dear Blog reader!  Do you believe that violence by abortion opponents is justifiable?  Do you think that public policy should reflect a trust of women to make their own personal reproductive decisions?  You may send an email to Blog@CherylKagan.org or click on the "Comments" link below to express your views.  Please be sure to indicate which post (#31) you're addressing.

Thanks for reading.  I will post again soon.

Comments

It seems ironic and paternalistic that most of the people who are the most outspoken and active in opposing women's rights of choice are men, and that is very troublesome, to me, about how many of my brothers feel about this issue. I often wonder if this decision affected these men's bodies the way it does women's if these men might have a different viewpoint. However, that is secondary, to the main issue. The main issue is that women have the inherent right of choice. That does not make people who believe this way "pro-abortion;" it simply means that people who believe this way believe in a woman's right to choose. No one, I think, is "pro-abortion" or "anti-life," while some who disagree with this consider themselves to be "pro-life;" everyone I know is pro-life, even if one believes in a woman's right to choose. I am concerned, though, that violent attacks on pro-choice clinics, legislation making it more difficult for pro-choice clinics to stay open, and politicians who are most interested in being elected or re-elected than taking a stand for pro-choice seem to be on the increase. Also, physicians are becoming more reluctant to practice pro-choice medicine, because of violent attacks, and because they have not been trained in pro-choice medicine, and other obstacles to pro-choice. Members of the Supreme Court, who are not pro-choice, stay on the bench, until a president from their own party who is not pro-choice gets elected, before they retire, and Roe v. Wade's margin in the Supreme Court hangs in the balance. Rather, women's choice, their very essence, hangs in the balance. It is very important, I believe, that we elect political leaders who support pro-choice, because pro-choice means pro-equality, for both women and men. To me, we should strive, and strive mightily, for the goal of equality, as a community, a State, and as a nation. To do anything less, demeans us, particularly us men. Let us not shame ourselves by our actions against women; let us lift them up, as they deserve dignity and respect. They deserve the right to make their own choices.
Posted by: Rev. John Cooper-Martin on Tuesday, January 26, 2010 at 12:51:00 pm

"You value freedom- -grant it to others." Great fortune. I always get the lamest cliches. You are a lucky person...I mean fortunate. :>) In answer to your ending questions- 1. No. Violence is a tool of ignorance (and choice). 2. Yes! I read on another blog about a bumper sticker that read something like, "If you don't trust me to make my own choice, why would you trust me to have a child?"... It sounded better than that but you get the gist... Thank you for sharing your thoughts on this important day. Peace...
Posted by: markprime on Friday, January 22, 2010 at 8:51:00 pm

Leave a Comment

Only your name will be posted with your comment, not your email.